Plot: Gumball took Madison, Tom, and Sylvester to Neverland and must stop Evil Martin Brisby from wreaking havoc.
Cast
- Peter Pan - Gumball Watterson (The Amazing World of Gumball)
- Wendy Darling - Madison Waltson (The Amazing World of Gumball)
- John Darling - Tom Cat Jr. (Tom & Jerry Kids)
- Michael Darling - Sylvester Toddler (Baby Looney Tunes)
- Tinker Bell - Dot (A Bug's Life)
- Captain Hook - Evil Martin Brisby (The Secret of NIMH II: Timmy to the Rescue)
- Mr. Smee - Sullivan (The Secret of NIMH)
- Tic-Toc the Crocodile - Lucifer (Cinderella) (as Jenner's enemy)
- The Lost Boys played by:
- Slightly the Fox Lostboy - Toothless (How to Train Your Dragon)
- Cubby the Bear Lostboy - Stormfly (How to Train Your Dragon)
- The Twins Lostboys - Barf & Blef (How to Train Your Dragon)
- Nibs the Rabbit Lostboy - Hookfang (How to Train Your Dragon)
- Tootles the Skunk Lostboy - Meatlug (How to Train Your Dragon)
- Princess Tiger Lily - Shine Ortiz (T.U.F.F. Puppy)
- The Indian Chief - Tiger (An American Tail)
- Nana - Pal (Arthur)
- Mary Darling - Sandy Waltson (The Amazing World of Gumball) (as Madison's mother)
- George Darling - Philip Waltson (The Amazing World of Gumball) (as Madison's father)
- Red-Haired Mermaid - Teresa (The Secret of NIMH)
- Black-Haired Mermaid - Minnie Mouse (Disney)
- Blonde-Haired Mermaid - Peepers (Rock-A-Doodle)
- Other Red-Haired Mermaid - Bridget (An American Tail)
- Other Black-Haired Mermaid - Tanya Mousekewitz (An American Tail 2: Fievel Goes West)
- Other Blonde-Haired Mermaid - Dot (A Bug's Life)
- The Indians - Flying Monkeys (The Wizard of Oz)
- Indian Squaw - Terk (Tarzan)
- Brave and Squaw - Frog Naveen and Frog Tiana (The Princess and the Frog)
- Brave's Mother-in-Law - Mrs. Toad (Thumbelina (1994))
- The Pirates - Prince John's Soldiers (Robin Hood)
Chapters
- The Second Star to the Right (Gumball version)
- Meet the Waltsons
- Meet Gumball Pan
- Evil Martin Brisby and his Soldiers
- The Lost Dragons
- Captured by the Flying Monkeys
- Captain Martin Brisby Kidnaps Shine Ortiz
- Gumball Fights Evil Martin Brisby at Skull Rock
- Captain Martin Brisby's New Plan
- What Makes the Fly Monkey Pink
- Dot Helps Captain Evil Martin Brisby
- Your Mother and Mine (Madison version)
- A Bomb for Gumball!
- Gumball's Final Battle with Captain Evil Martin Brisby
- Philip Waltson apologizes to Madison Waltson