Plot: Fievel took Olivia, Timothy, and Jaq to Neverland and must stop Jenner from wreaking havoc.


  • Peter Pan - Fievel Mousekewitz (An American Tail)
  • Wendy Darling - Olivia Flaversham (The Great Mouse Detective)
  • John Darling - Timothy Q. Mouse (Dumbo) (as Olivia's big brother)
  • Michael Darling - Jaq (Cinderella) (as Olivia's little brother)
  • Tinker Bell - Dot (A Bug's Life)
  • Captain Hook - Jenner (The Secret of NIMH)
  • Mr. Smee - Sullivan (The Secret of NIMH)
  • Tic-Toc the Crocodile - Dragon (The Secret of NIMH) (as Jenner's enemy)
  • The Lost Boys played by:
    • Slightly the Fox Lostboy - Jim Crow (Dumbo)
    • Cubby the Bear Lostboy - Fat Crow (Dumbo)
    • The Twins Lostboys - Preacher Crow and Straw Hat Crow (Dumbo)
    • Nibs the Rabbit Lostboy - Jeremy (The Secret of NIMH)
    • Tootles the Skunk Lostboy - Glasses Crow (Dumbo)
  • Princess Tiger Lily - Cholena (An American Tail 3: The Treasure of Manhattan Island)
  • The Indian Chief - Chief Wulisso (An American Tail 3: The Treasure of Manhattan Island)
  • Nana - Pal (Arthur)
  • Mary Darling - Mama Mousekewitz (An American Tail) (as Olivia's mother)
  • George Darling - Papa Mousekewitz (An American Tail) (as Olivia's father)
  • Red-Haired Mermaid - Teresa (The Secret of NIMH)
  • Black-Haired Mermaid - Minnie Mouse (Disney)
  • Blonde-Haired Mermaid - Peepers (Rock-A-Doodle)
  • Other Red-Haired Mermaid - Bridget (An American Tail)
  • Other Black-Haired Mermaid - Tanya Mousekewitz (An American Tail 2: Fievel Goes West)
  • Other Blonde-Haired Mermaid - Dot (A Bug's Life)
  • The Indians - Pink Elephants (Dumbo)
  • Indian Squaw - Terk (Tarzan)
  • Brave and Squaw - Frog Naveen and Frog Tiana (The Princess and the Frog)
  • Brave's Mother-in-Law - Mrs. Toad (Thumbelina (1994))
  • The Pirates - Prince John's Soldiers (Robin Hood)


Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.